Last Updated on November 15, 2022 by Lily Connel
On the plus side, closing the border would mean that fewer people would be able to come into the country illegally. It would also help to reduce crime, as many criminals cross the border illegally. However, there are also several potential downsides to consider. For one, it would be bad for the economy, as many businesses rely on immigrant labour. It would also make it more difficult for people who legitimately need to cross the border – such as those travelling for medical reasons – to do so.
The idea of closing the border has been gaining traction among some Americans in recent months, as the debate over immigration reform continues. Ultimately, whether or not closing the border is a good idea is a matter of opinion. There are valid arguments for and against it. But whichever side you come down on, it’s important to be informed about the issue
Pros and Cons Of Closing The Border – The Differences
| Serial | Pros Of Closing The Border | Cons Of Closing The Border |
| 1. | In the United States, a large percentage of crime is committed by illegal immigrants. | If the border is closed, it will be more difficult for people to attend school in the US without proper documentation, which will reduce the number of illegal immigrants who are currently attending school here. |
| 2. | Illegal immigrants often take the jobs that Americans would otherwise have. | Closing the border would help reduce the burden on social services. |
| 3. | Businesses across our country would lose revenue if they closed the border. | Closing the border would improve our national security. |
| 4. | Shutting down the border would be bad for the economy. | If we do this, we will be sure that Americans come first for jobs. |
| 5. | It is not acceptable to violate human rights by preventing immigrants from entering or leaving our country. | If we cut down on immigration, crime rates would go down. |
| 6. | Imports will decrease due to regulatory compliance issues. | Illegal immigrants cost taxpayers billions of dollars every year. |
| 7. | The border is unsafe. Crime and violence are on the rise. | The border wall is a great way to deter illegal Immigration. |
Pros Of Closing The Border
1. Illegal Immigration
Closing the border would deter illegal immigration. It is a well-known fact that when you make it more difficult for people to do something, they are less likely to do it. By closing the border, we would be making it more difficult for people to cross into our country illegally, which would hopefully reduce the number of illegal immigrants.
2. Cost of Benefits
Illegal immigrants cost taxpayers billions of dollars every year in government benefits such as food stamps, healthcare, and housing subsidies. If we closed the border, we could save taxpayers billions of dollars each year.
3. Crime Rate
Illegal immigrants are responsible for a large percentage of crime in the United States. For example, a recent study found that up to 75% of all murders in Arizona were committed by illegal immigrants. If we closed the border, we would be able to reduce crime rates nationwide.
4. Jobs
Illegal immigrants often take jobs away from American citizens. By closing the border, we would be ensuring that American citizens have priority for jobs in our country.
5. Language Barrier
Closing the border would help to reduce the number of people in our country who do not speak English. This would make it easier for everyone to communicate and function effectively in our society.
6. National Security
Closing the border would improve our national security by making it more difficult for terrorists and criminals to enter our country.
7. Social Services
Closing the border would help to reduce the burden on social services such as schools, hospitals, and prisons.
8. Education
Closing the border would make it more difficult for people to attend school in the United States without proper documentation, which would help to reduce the number of illegal immigrants who are currently attending school here.
9. Healthcare
Closing the border would help to reduce the number of illegal immigrants who receive free healthcare in our country. This would save taxpayers billions of dollars each year.
10. Welfare
Closing the border would help to reduce the number of illegal immigrants who receive welfare benefits in our country. This would save taxpayers billions of dollars each year.
11. Voting
Closing the border would help to reduce the number of illegal immigrants who vote in our elections. This is because it would be more difficult for them to register to vote, and it would be more difficult for them to vote because they are not in the country legally.
12. The Taxpayers
Closing the border would reduce our tax burden. It has been estimated that illegal immigrants cost us around $113 billion every year. This includes costs of educating their children, healthcare costs resulting from treating them in emergency rooms, and incarceration costs for housing illegal immigrant criminals who break the law (which also costs taxpayers over $1 billion per year). If we closed the border, we could save taxpayers billions of dollars each year.
13. Environment
Closing the border would help protect our environment by reducing pollution caused by transporting people across long distances to get here illegally.
14. Illegal Drug Trade
Illegal immigrants are responsible for transporting illegal drugs into the United States. By closing the border, we would be reducing the amount of money that cartels make by trafficking drugs into our country. We could also reduce addiction rates in our country if we closed the border because it would disrupt drug production and distribution inside our own country.
15. The Rule Of Law
Closing the border would help to ensure that our country is following the rule of law by preventing people from entering our country illegally. This would protect both American citizens and legal immigrants who are currently in our country, by ensuring that everyone is following the same rules and regulations.
16. Human Trafficking
Closing the border would help to reduce the number of people who are trafficked into our country for sex or labour. This is because it would be more difficult for them to get into the country, and it would be more difficult for them to survive here without proper documentation.
17. The Economy
Closing the border would help to improve our economy by reducing the number of jobs that are taken away from American citizens, as well as reducing the amount of money that we spend on social services for illegal immigrants. It has also been estimated that closing the border could create up to 1.2 million jobs in our country due to an increase in production and a decrease in imports.
18. National Safety
Closing the border would make our country safer by reducing the number of illegal immigrants who are currently residing in or travelling through our country, some of whom may be members of gangs like MS-13. Closing the border would help to reduce crime rates nationwide while protecting legal citizens from becoming victims of criminal activity.
19. The Future
Maintaining a secure border is necessary for maintaining national security and sovereignty, which are essential components of being a strong nation with a bright future. By closing our borders, we can protect ourselves from countries that have high levels of violence and lack proper institutions – making it impossible for them to maintain order in society – allowing us to continue existing as a successful nation into the future.
Cons Of Closing The Border
1. Jobs Lost
Closing the border would result in Americans losing their jobs because illegal immigrants are currently doing many of them for much cheaper than American citizens, resulting in a loss of opportunities for legal workers. This disproportionately affects lower-class communities that have lost opportunities for economic advancement to illegal immigrants who work for less money.
2. Businesses Lose Money
Businesses across our country could lose revenue by closing the border, which could affect overall employment rates nationwide, as well as tax revenues collected from businesses across all industries. Closing the border would take away potential customers who rely on exports to other countries where they don’t make nearly as much money as they do here – leaving us without potentially hundreds of billions of dollars worth of international products.
3. The Economy Suffers
Closing the border would also hurt our economy as a whole because we would be losing out on opportunities to do business with other countries, as well as losing tax revenue and jobs. This would lead to a decrease in our overall wealth as a nation, and could even result in another recession.
4. Social Services Increased
Illegal immigrants are currently using social services like healthcare and education at rates that are much higher than Americans, which is costing us billions of dollars every year. Closing the border would prevent illegal immigrants from accessing these social services, which would save us money while also reducing the amount of stress that our social programs are currently under.
5. Human Rights Violations
Closing the border would violate human rights by preventing people from travelling into or out of our country, no matter what their needs may be. Human rights are universal and must be respected by all countries – regardless of how successful they are.
6. Illegal Imports
By closing the border, we would lose many products that are currently imported illegally because it is harder for smugglers to bring their goods across the ocean than through an open land border. This would lead to a decrease in production among factories that rely on imported materials, which could result in job loss everywhere across our global economy.
7. Costly Regulation
Closing our borders could cause international trade prices to increase exponentially as well as reduce imports due to regulatory compliance issues outside of America. This would make it harder for American companies to compete internationally, as well as increase the prices of many products that we import from other countries.
8. The Human Toll
Closing our borders could lead to human rights violations, which is something that the United States must always avoid when pursuing a path that will benefit us – especially considering how much attention we have put on this issue in other countries. Closing the border would be a violation of human rights by keeping people from entering or leaving our country.
9. Crime And Violence Increase
If we close our borders, crime rates across America will begin to rise significantly because illegal immigrants commit crimes at rates much higher than legal residents or American citizens do – meaning they are more likely to flee if deported. This will lead to a rise in crime at all levels across America, including violent crimes that are likely to harm American citizens.
10. Who We Are As Americans
Closing the border would fundamentally change what it means to be an American because our nation was built on immigration – with many of the most important events in our history revolving around immigrants who chose to make this country their home. Closing the borders goes against everything that makes us unique and special as a people, which is another reason why we should not allow this option to become viable for political reasons in 2016 or beyond.
11. Social Contagion
People across the world are closely following the elections in America because they have strong opinions about what we do here – especially when it comes to immigration. If we close our borders, it would send a message to the world that America is no longer open to immigrants, which could lead to a number of social and political problems that we may not be able to solve.
12. Economic Damage
Closing our borders would have a significant negative impact on our economy because we would be losing out on opportunities to do business with other countries, as well as losing tax revenue and jobs. This would lead to a decrease in our overall wealth as a nation.
13. The Way Forward
We are a country that was built on immigration, and closing our borders would be an incredibly drastic step that goes against everything we stand for as Americans. It would also have significant negative consequences for our economy, social fabric, and international relationships. We should not close our borders and should instead pursue a path that embraces immigration and makes us stronger as a nation.
14. National Security Risks
Closing our borders could lead to an increase in national security risks because it would be much harder for us to track potential terrorists or criminals who are trying to enter the country. This could make it easier for them to sneak into America and do harm to our citizens.
15. Loss Of Global Influence
Closing our borders would also mean that America would lose its global influence because we would no longer be seen as a country that is open to immigrants and willing to work with other nations.
Conclusion
Closing the borders should not be entertained as an option because it would have negative consequences that we cannot possibly foresee at this time. We should instead embrace the fact that America was built on immigration and work to make things easier for those who wish to come here legally.
